Should You Mentor or Fire Your Struggling Employee?

What should you do when an employee struggles to meet expectations?  

The decision between mentoring an employee to help them improve or letting them go to find a better fit is always challenging. Both options come with their own set of benefits and costs.  

Here are some ideas to help you make the best decision for your business.

The Case for Mentoring

1. Retaining Industry Knowledge and Experience

The building products industry is highly specialized, requiring knowledge of materials, product specifications, supply chain management, and customer preferences. Mentoring could be a strategic move if the struggling employee has experience or company-specific knowledge. You can capitalize on their existing knowledge base while addressing performance issues by providing additional support and training.

2. Boosting Employee Morale and Loyalty

Investing time in mentoring shows employees that they are valued and worth the effort, which can significantly boost morale. This approach can increase loyalty and dedication from the individual being mentored and the rest of the team who see that the company values its people.  

3. Cost-Effective Solution

Firing an employee and hiring a replacement involves substantial costs, including time without someone in that seat, time and cost of hiring, and training for the new hire.  

Mentoring, on the other hand, is generally less expensive.  

It allows you to address performance issues while saving on the costs associated with turnover. Additionally, retaining an employee means you keep the investment already made in their training and development.

4. Improved Productivity Over Time

Through mentoring, struggling employees can develop their skills and become more effective contributors to the company. Mentoring can address these gaps by identifying the root causes of their struggles—whether it's a lack of specific skills, poor communication, or inadequate understanding of company processes.  

This approach can lead to long-term improvements in productivity and performance, benefitting the company as a whole.

The Case for Firing

1. Immediate Performance Improvement Needs

Sometimes, a struggling employee’s performance issues are severe enough to directly impact the team’s ability to meet goals, maintain quality, or ensure safety.  

If an employee cannot meet these critical performance standards even with mentoring, letting them go might be the only option to ensure the team's success.

2. Protecting Company Culture

An employee who consistently underperforms, even after receiving mentoring, can negatively impact the workplace environment.  

They may cause frustration among other team members who must compensate for their shortcomings, leading to decreased morale and productivity. Firing might be the best way to preserve a positive, motivated work culture aligning with the company’s values and standards.

3. Avoiding the Sunk Cost Fallacy

It’s important to recognize when mentoring is not working. Continuing to invest time and resources into an employee who is unlikely to improve can drain company resources.  

If it becomes apparent that mentoring is not making a significant difference, it might be more pragmatic to let the employee go and find someone who can more effectively meet the company’s needs.

Weighing the Decision

Before deciding whether to mentor or fire a struggling employee, consider the following:

• Performance History: Has the employee shown potential in the past, or is this a recurring issue? A history of solid performance may indicate that mentoring could be successful.
  ‍

• Willingness to Learn: Is the employee open to feedback and willing to improve? Mentoring may be ineffective if they are resistant to change or unwilling to put in the effort to improve.
  ‍

• Impact on the Team: How does the employee’s performance affect the rest of the team? If it’s causing significant disruption or dissatisfaction, action may be needed sooner rather than later.
  ‍

• Resource Availability: Do you have the resources—time, personnel, and budget—to mentor effectively? If not, it might be more practical to hire someone new.
  ‍

Conclusion

Deciding whether to mentor or fire a struggling is a critical decision. Mentoring can help retain valuable knowledge, improve morale, and save costs, but it requires commitment and resources.  

By evaluating the situation thoughtfully, you can make a decision that best supports your team and business goals.

Need help making the right hiring decisions or finding the perfect fit for your team? Contact us.

‍